Frequently Searched

Michigan health care ruling fails economics test

November 19, 2014

A federal court in Michigan recently ignored reasoning used by other judges in Virginia and Florida and dismissed a private lawsuit against the federal health care reform law. The judge in Michigan relied on an argument by Congress that mandating everyone to have insurance will eventually lower overall costs for health care. But that line of thinking disregards a half-century of experience with health insurance in the United States.

In 1960, when Americans paid almost half of all medical costs out of their pockets, health care costs were roughly the same as in 1935 when compared to the cost of other goods and services. By 2006, when Americans paid less than 13 percent of their medical costs out-of-pocket, overall health care costs had more than doubled compared to everything else.

In other words, costs went up, not down, as Americans became more dependent on health insurance. While it’s true insurance becomes cheaper when people unlikely to make a claim pay for it anyway, this has no bearing on the cost of health care that people buy insurance to cover.

The federal judges in Virginia and Florida are interested in economic reality and constitutional principles, which is why they are closely considering the legal challenges to federal health care reform. And that’s why the Goldwater Institute is pursuing another lawsuit here in Arizona on behalf of private citizens and federal and state lawmakers who want real reforms to make health care more affordable.

Dr. Byron Schlomach is an economist and director of the Center for Economic Prosperity at the Goldwater Institute.

Learn More:

Goldwater Institute: Removing the Middleman: What States Can Do to Make Health Care More Responsive to Patients

Goldwater Institute: Coons v. Geithner

Washington Post: The health-insurance mandate is found to be legally sound (in Michigan)

Fox News: Constitutional or Not? Debate over Obamacare continues

 

 

More on this issue

Donate Now

Help all Americans live freer, happier lives. Join the Goldwater Institute as we defend and strengthen freedom in all 50 states.

Donate Now

Since 1988, the Goldwater Institute has been in the liberty business — defending and promoting freedom, and achieving more than 400 victories in all 50 states. Donate today to help support our mission.

We Protect Your Rights

Our attorneys defend individual rights and protect those who cannot protect themselves.

Need Help? Submit a case.

Get Connected to Goldwater

Sign up for the latest news, event updates, and more.

Wait! Don’t close this yet!

We are grateful for your support of the Goldwater Institute’s efforts to advance and defend liberty throughout the United States. For over 36 years, we’ve been defending the rights of Americans to live their lives free from government interference.

And Goldwater is unique in that we direct our efforts to the 50 states where we introduce and advance innovative ideas that expand freedom. And we fight in courtrooms and capitals nationwide to defend individual liberty.

In 2024 alone, we scored over 50 policy and litigation victories defending liberty!

And that’s just the beginning.

Our plans for 2025 include:

  • Stopping pernicious DEI and other woke programs in America’s universities.
  • Ensuring that patients suffering from rare and terminal diseases have access to cutting-edge, lifesaving medical treatments, without having to first seek permission from the government.
  • Defending parental rights across the United States so that parents can send their kids to the school that best fits their needs, free from leftist indoctrination.
  • Eliminating government interference in the fundamental right of individuals to own property and use it as they see fit.
  • And much, much more

We seek to restore the presumption of liberty; that people are free to act without first asking permission from the government.

But we cannot do this without you. Will you join us as we fight to preserve and advance liberty throughout the country? As we seek new and innovative ways to defend freedom in all 50 states?

And there’s great news: Thanks to a generous Goldwater supporter, your donation today will be doubled!

So please, join us in fighting to advance liberty and score real wins for freedom from coast to coast!