There’s no doubt that providing students with a robust education comes with real costs—but what exactly do limos, casinos, amusement parks and go-karts have to do with educating kids?
The Tolleson Union High School District in Arizona has been spending public money on all that and more, but when the Goldwater Institute asked for the paperwork to back up its payments, the district responded with a $13,000 price tag. That’s not transparency; it’s a “keep out” sign, which is why Goldwater and its American Freedom Network of pro-bono attorneys are suing the district to ensure it is up front about how it’s spending tax dollars.
Tolleson’s purchase orders, invoices, and receipts are public records, and Arizona law guarantees the right to inspect them. In March, the Goldwater Institute requested all the district’s purchase orders for the 2024-25 fiscal year. Tolleson refused to turn over the electronic files and insisted on printing them at $1 per page—at a cost of $13,000—because, in the words of Superintendent Jeremy Calles, the district doesn’t “gift electricity for witch hunts.” In August, Goldwater submitted a request for the paperwork behind just 37 questionable payments. Again, the district refused to provide the files electronically.
But this is no witch hunt, and those payments show why the details matter. They include:
- $35,400 for advertising
- $32,930 for employee coaching and leadership development
- $15,670.84 to a limousine company
- $6,320.97 to the Arrowhead Country Club in Glendale
- $2,635 at Knott’s Berry Farm, a California amusement park
- $1,514.94 at Andretti Indoor Karting and Games
- Several travel charges at the Casino Del Sol and Meritage Resort
If district leaders have good explanations for these purchases, they should let people know. But a one-line ledger entry doesn’t tell the public anything about what exactly the district is spending money on.
Arizona public records law favors transparency. Agencies may charge reasonable copying fees, but they cannot bill for staff time spent searching for records. Most Arizona families couldn’t pay a $13,000 fee to inspect records, and that appears to be the point. Setting the price of transparency that high is the same as denying the request.
That’s why Goldwater partnered with American Freedom Network attorney Greg Iannelli to enforce its right to inspect the district’s records without unreasonable fees.
“Public records belong to the public, not to district administrators,” Iannelli said. “A five-figure bill for receipts the district already has isn’t a fee—it’s a wall. The law doesn’t allow for it, and we’re asking the court to take it down.”
The stakes go beyond one school district. If Tolleson can name its own price for secrecy, so can every public body, leaving taxpayers to pay for the privilege of seeing how their money is spent.
“These records exist electronically, and that’s how we asked to receive them,” said Stacy Skankey, the Goldwater Institute’s American Freedom Network Litigation Director. “There is no reason to print them out, charge $1 a page, and put them in the mail. We sent the same request to another school district at the same time, and that district delivered its records promptly, electronically, and for free. Tolleson’s fees are not a cost of doing business. They’re a tactic to deny access.”
Government officials who spend taxpayer money don’t get to hide the receipts. Goldwater’s lawsuit will ensure that Tolleson explains why it thinks it can.
Click here to read the Goldwater Institute’s lawsuit against the Tolleson Union High School District.
The Goldwater Institute’s American Freedom Network of pro bono attorneys work closely with the Institute on cases and projects that advance liberty around the country, on matters ranging from free speech to taxpayer rights to government transparency. As part of Goldwater’s pro bono network, participating attorneys will have the opportunity to work on issues that interest them, litigating meaningful cases in a way that makes sense for their practice.
Click here to learn more and join the network.